FCA Consultation on Fees & Levies for 2024/25

Members may have seen that the FCA issued their annual consultation on the fees charged to firms on Tuesday 9th March – AMI comments…

Consumer Duty has made vulnerability about ‘characteristics’ rather than ‘binary’

Chloe Timperley’s comments from the British Specialist Lending Senate 2024 regulatory expectations around vulnerability…

Your March update from AMI Chief Executive Robert Sinclair

AMI Chief Executive Robert Sinclair gives his March update, including the Mortgage Charter and the FCA annual business plan…

Sexism in the City feedback: recommendations for firms

The feedback report for the September Sexism in the City paper has been released. We are cited in the report, relating to our event code of conduct…

AI will not replace ‘divergent or creative’ thinking

Chloe Timperley’s comments from the British Specialist Lending Senate 2024 on generative AI and regulatory expectations around vulnerability…

Mortgage Brokers: The climate is changing, should you?

The Mortgage Climate Action Group (MCAG) is delighted to invite you to its upcoming webinar: ‘The Climate is Changing, Should You?’ on 18th March at 10am…

Edit Content

Log in here for full access to all our great content


Please log in below with your username (which is your email address), using all lower-case letters.


Forgotten your password?
No problem, simply tell us you have forgotten your password to receive instructions instantly via email.

Having problems logging in?
If you are a current member but are unable to login, please first make sure you are using all lower-case letters for your username/email address. If you still have difficulties, please contact us via email at info@a-m-i.org.uk so we can rectify your problem.

Not a member?
Learn more about the benefits of becoming a member or apply online and we will be in touch.

Why did I watch Andrew Bailey appear before the Treasury Select Committee?  Because he was being interviewed about his part in the London Capital & Finance failure and the report by Dame Elisabeth Gloster that apportioned blame on him for the failure of the FCA to use its authorisation and supervisory powers appropriately.

This has led to the FSCS paying out millions in compensation that, having breached two class limits, respectable mortgage and protection firms are having to pay for.

As a chess player caught in the moment of hearing the words “Check”; the former Head of the FCA and now Governor of the Bank of England produced a stunning new defence worthy of the Grand Master he is.  He delivered at the Treasury Select Committee the explanation that it was crucial that we all understood that as Chief Executive he was of course responsible for what happened, but not culpable.

To give context the statement in the FCA Annual Report of 2015/16 from the chair, John Griffith-Jones should be recalled that, “I was pleased that Andrew Bailey, a longstanding member of our Board, was appointed as Chief Executive from 1 July 2016.  Andrew gives us the continuity of a Chief Executive who understands our organisation, our statutory objectives and the diversity of the sectors we regulate.”  The fact that he had been on the Board since April 2013 meant that perhaps he should have known more about the issues he recalled on taking the job.  His surprise that the call centre was outsourced, should not have been.

This of course now provides an excellent new approach for all those captured under the Senior Managers Regime to similarly shrug off their responsibilities with the same cutely orchestrated device.  It is great when those on the side of “right” use language to expunge their failure to provide their organisation with the appropriate direction, but if it has led to loss then being responsible and apologising for their loss is enough.  Not an apology for the failure to do the job they were being paid by good firms to do.  Indeed, at points despite the FCA accepting all of the findings and recommendations, the Governor still appeared to dispute aspects of the report.

So with one bound, he was free.  Out of “Check”, able to carry on, with his interview littered with statements about his inability to comment on the FCA as he left over a year ago, or that he was sure Nikhil Rathi could fill in on that gap.

What was clear is that he knew the FCA was not up to standard, there were programmes to change how it operated, but in his view unfortunately it just did not happen quickly enough.  He was responsible but not culpable.  That is a line I hope I never have to even think about using.

Robert Sinclair
Chief Executive, AMI


Forgot Password?

Join Us